Close Menu
Capital.ba – Informacija je capitalCapital.ba – Informacija je capital
  • POČETNA
  • SVE VIJESTI
  • CAPITAL TEME
    • ANALIZE
    • EKSKLUZIVNO
    • INTERVJU
  • NOVOSTI
  • PRIVREDA
    • ENERGETIKA
    • FINANSIJE
    • TRŽIŠTE KAPITALA
    • TRGOVINA
    • TURIZAM
  • TECH
  • SVIJET
    • ZANIMLJIVOSTI
  • MULTIMEDIJA
    •   Video
    • Foto Galerija
    • Infografika
  • PROMO
Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram LinkedIn YouTube Viber
Capital.ba – Informacija je capitalCapital.ba – Informacija je capital
Donacije
  • POČETNA
  • SVE VIJESTI
  • CAPITAL TEME
    1. ANALIZE
    2. EKSKLUZIVNO
    3. INTERVJU
    4. Vidi sve

    Simbioza na djelu: Stanivuković i SNSD poklonili milionski vrijedno gradsko zemljište

    7. Augusta 2024. — 13:00

    Ekonomisti: Republici Srpskoj prijeti finansijska katastrofa

    6. Juna 2024. — 14:10

    Za Radukića ministri u Vladi Srpske rade savršeno

    20. Maja 2024. — 13:56

    Srbija ubrzano isisava energente iz BiH

    29. Decembra 2023. — 14:05

    Ekskluzivno: CAPITAL otkriva imena uhapšenih carinika

    16. Decembra 2024. — 10:47

    Saznajemo: Uskoro optužnica protiv Đoke Ekvatora

    28. Juna 2024. — 13:46

    Ekskluzivno: Optuženi u aferi „korona ugovori“ priznaje krivicu

    19. Juna 2024. — 10:43

    Nakon „Alumine“, Pavlović preuzima i „Boksit“

    16. Maja 2024. — 12:15

    Tanić za CAPITAL: Na domaćem tržištu više ne možemo kupiti ni cijevi za grijanje

    21. Marta 2025. — 20:10

    Kako je Širbegović od posuđenih 1.500 KM došao do milionskog profita

    14. Marta 2025. — 19:55

    Smailbegović: Odnos države i poslodavaca zasniva se na poznanstvima

    7. Marta 2025. — 20:00

    Mujanić: BiH ima zaliha domaćeg mesa samo za tri dana

    21. Februara 2025. — 20:05

    „Planet Soft“ i „Dwelt“ u trci za izradu softvera ERS

    9. Juna 2025. — 14:18

    Novinarka CAPITAL-a nagrađena za izvještavanje o švercu duvana

    9. Juna 2025. — 14:06

    Radišić ponovo jedini dostavio ponudu za zgradu UIO

    9. Juna 2025. — 12:36

    EKSKLUZIVNO: Direktor IRB-a podnio ostavku

    9. Juna 2025. — 10:39
  • NOVOSTI
  • PRIVREDA
    1. ENERGETIKA
    2. FINANSIJE
    3. TRŽIŠTE KAPITALA
    4. TRGOVINA
    5. TURIZAM
    6. Vidi sve

    „Planet Soft“ i „Dwelt“ u trci za izradu softvera ERS

    9. Juna 2025. — 14:18

    Evropa se vraća nuklearnoj energiji

    2. Juna 2025. — 12:12

    Uvoz struje u BiH za godinu dana skočio čak 518,2 odsto

    2. Juna 2025. — 09:09

    Dodatnih 88 miliona evra za investicije u zelenoj tranziciji

    30. Maja 2025. — 13:58

    Viaduct nema račun, BiH ne zna kome da isplati novac

    9. Juna 2025. — 15:33

    Promet na berzi veći od 70.000 KM

    9. Juna 2025. — 13:50

    Evo koliko iznosi njemačka penzija nakon 45 godina rada

    9. Juna 2025. — 11:45

    Depoziti narasli na 34,22 milijarde KM

    9. Juna 2025. — 10:30

    „Eastcode“ povećao vlasništvo u „Veleprehrani“  

    30. Maja 2025. — 10:24

    „Atlantik“ novom milionskom emisijom obveznica vraća stari dug

    28. Maja 2025. — 13:26

    Promet akcijama “Veleprehrane” vrijedan 126.100 KM

    26. Maja 2025. — 14:23

    Oštar pad Vol Strita

    22. Maja 2025. — 11:03

    Tržište automobila u BiH: Cijene skaču, a vozila nema na stanju

    7. Juna 2025. — 14:02

    Vlada FBiH produžila mjeru ‘zaključavanja’ cijena za 65 proizvoda

    2. Juna 2025. — 16:26

    Još jedan proizvod se povlači iz dm prodavnica

    2. Juna 2025. — 13:44

    Čak 77 odsto Crnogoraca odjeću kupovalo preko interneta

    2. Juna 2025. — 10:17

    Hotel na šinama uskoro prolazi kroz Banjaluku

    9. Juna 2025. — 15:00

    Norveška uvodi turističku taksu

    8. Juna 2025. — 10:14

    Ljetovanje iz snova: Sedam noćenja za 100 evra

    7. Juna 2025. — 10:52

    Jedno od omiljenih ljetovališta u Crnoj Gori počinje da naplaćuje ulaz

    6. Juna 2025. — 14:46

    „Planet Soft“ i „Dwelt“ u trci za izradu softvera ERS

    9. Juna 2025. — 14:18

    Ribnjak “Saničani” ima novog stečajnog upravnika

    9. Juna 2025. — 10:00

    Rast BDP-a Republike Srpske usporio na 1,5 odsto u prvom kvartalu

    3. Juna 2025. — 16:15

    Evropa se vraća nuklearnoj energiji

    2. Juna 2025. — 12:12
  • TECH
  • SVIJET
    1. ZANIMLJIVOSTI
    2. Vidi sve

    Hotel na šinama uskoro prolazi kroz Banjaluku

    9. Juna 2025. — 15:00

    Kako je Starbucks osvojio kupce trikom od četiri dolara

    8. Juna 2025. — 14:24

    Ljetovanje iz snova: Sedam noćenja za 100 evra

    7. Juna 2025. — 10:52

    Musk izgubio 34 milijarde dolara u jednom danu

    7. Juna 2025. — 09:02

    Proizvođač pelena Pampers otpušta 7.000 ljudi

    6. Juna 2025. — 14:03

    Raspoloženje u njemačkoj stanogradnji poboljšano, ali i dalje na niskom nivou

    6. Juna 2025. — 11:50

    Moguće povećanje minimalne satnice u Njemačkoj sve je bliže

    6. Juna 2025. — 08:14

    OECD smanjio prognozu rasta svjetske ekonomije

    5. Juna 2025. — 09:02
  • MULTIMEDIJA
    •   Video
    • Foto Galerija
    • Infografika
  • PROMO
Capital.ba – Informacija je capitalCapital.ba – Informacija je capital
  • POČETNA
  • SVE VIJESTI
  • CAPITAL TEME
  • NOVOSTI
  • PRIVREDA
  • ENERGETIKA
  • TURIZAM
  • TRGOVINA
  • TRŽIŠTE KAPITALA
  • TECH
  • ZANIMLJIVOSTI
  • SVIJET
  • FINANSIJE
  •   VIDEO
  • PROMO
Home » Public procurement in KCUS: One bidder each for equipment worth 4 million KM

Public procurement in KCUS: One bidder each for equipment worth 4 million KM

Bojana NinkovicBojana Ninkovic18. Februara 2023. — 15:37Nema komentara7 minuta čitanja
izvor: fokus.ba

SARAJEVO – During 2022, the Clinical Center of the University in Sarajevo acquired at least 20 different devices worth about 4 million KM through a public procurement procedure for which one bidder applied. Directors of several hospitals in Bosnia and Herzegovina, refusing to speak publicly about public procurement, appreciate that there is competition in the medical equipment market in Bosnia and Herzegovina. They warn that it is probably either an agreement between the bidders or a very precisely copied description of the requested goods.

izvor: fokus.ba

In 2022, the Clinical Center of the University in Sarajevo acquired at least 20 different devices more expensive than 100,000 KM (total value of about 4 million KM) through a public procurement procedure for which one bidder applied.

These are, among other things, the following devices: 4D ultrasound machine, gamma counter, plasma sterilizer, electroencephalogram EEG machine, electromyograph EMG… transcranial Doppler TCD, colour doppler ultrasound machine, monitors for monitoring vital parameters, mini excavator, EKG machine 6/12 channel on a mobile cart, system for ventricular support of the heart (LVAD, RVAD, BiVAD and ECMO), machine for extracorporeal circulation (heart-lung), mobile X-ray machine with C-arm… (https://www. ejn.gov.ba/Registry/CASearch).

What do auditors look for first?

The Chief Auditor at the Institutional Audit Office in the FBiH Dževad Nekić says that he knows nothing about specific procurements by KCUS. However, he adds that auditors generally in public procurements first check the tender documentation to determine whether a supplier has been preferred by the invitation itself, that is, whether the possibility of competition has been ensured, that is, that several suppliers have applied.

“It is symptomatic that often only one bidder appears, because competition exists everywhere, in all areas. However, it is always possible to exclude all but one of the interested suppliers with some detail in the tender documentation. Even in these cases, it is difficult to recognize what prevents active competition and favours a particular supplier. In addition, it is also important how many potential bidders took over the tender documentation”, says Nekić.

 

On the remark that in 2021, when KCUS bought 9 respirators (DRAGERWERK) from the company Diamedic from Sarajevo for 626,429.70 KM, 26 potential bidders took over the tender documentation, Nakić says that it is already strange.

 

“If potential bidders downloaded the documentation and did not send an offer – they must have found details there that made them unqualified. For example, we often come across a situation where, for example, mines buy a certain service, and as a request in the tender they very precisely specify the equipment that the supplier must have and thus make all others unqualified”, explains Nekić.

(Un)fair treatment

From the Agency for Public Procurement, director Sanja Ćubela points out:

“If the contracting authority respects the principle of equal treatment of all participants in the procedure in all stages of the public procurement procedure, and the bidder’s interest in the specific procurement is reduced, and the contracting authority receives only one or a small number of bids “, there can be no talk of irregularities on the part of the contracting authority.

However, they add that if the contracting authority does not respect the stated principles, and behaves unequally towards bidders through the public procurement procedure, for example favouring a certain bidder in a certain way, such behaviour may be subject to misdemeanour or criminal prosecution.

 

In addition, Ćubela clarifies that since 2018, the tender documentation for all completed public procurements is permanently available on the Public Procurement Portal https://www.ejn.gov.ba/ in the status of completed 60 days after the end of the public procurement, that is, the award of the contract.

 

What is the collusion?

Transparency International in BiH warns that public procurement based on only one offer is not prohibited. They also point out that there are probably few suppliers of medical equipment. However, they do not deny that there is also the possibility of suppliers colluding.

“It is not unusual for one bidder to apply for a tender. According to the data of the Agency for Public Procurement in Bosnia and Herzegovina, we often do not even have two offers. The average is 1.8 offers per tender. But, when it comes to purchases of higher value – it is a noticeable phenomenon that, in addition to contracting authorities agreeing with suppliers, suppliers agree when who will enter which tender because then they do not lower the prices and there are no complaints. This phenomenon is called collusion, it is extremely pronounced in practice. As far as we know – the Agency for Public Procurement in BiH will ask the Ministry of Justice to introduce this criminal offence into the Criminal Code of BiH. Because now it is difficult to prosecute the perpetrators of crimes among the suppliers. With the introduction of collusion in the criminal code, this problem will be solved”,  Damjan Ožegović, the senior researcher at TI BiH, is convinced.

Amendments to the Criminal Code

From Agency for Public Procurement Mostar, Sanja Ćubela, points out that this proposal for amendments to the Criminal Code of Bosnia and Herzegovina stipulates that a person responsible for a bidder or an entrepreneur who submits an offer based on false information or based on a prohibited agreement between bidders in the public procurement process will be punished with a prison sentence of six months to five years and a fine. And for acts in the public procurement procedure with a value greater than one million KM, the proposed prison sentence is from one to ten years and a fine from 1,000 to 5,000 KM, and for a legal entity from 5,000 to 50,000 KM.

“It is evident that in practice there is a phenomenon of a reduced number of bidders, submission of false information, division of the market, and fictitious offers, that bidders enter into agreements by completely faking the competition for public procurement contracts, agree on lowering prices, thereby pushing other bidders out of the public procurement procedure, distorting competition, the sudden withdrawal of the offer, different prices in different places, which basically has a fraudulent purpose, that is, acceptance of an offer based on prohibited agreements or false information. The perpetrator is the person who submitted the offer in the public procurement procedure. the form of guilt is premeditated-dolus. This practically means that the perpetrator acts with a certain goal, which is to accept the offer, and in these cases, there is no reference to delusion because the participants in the public procurement procedure cannot plead ignorance of the Law on Public Procurement. The essence of the mentioned criminal offence is that it was committed regardless of whether the criminal goal was achieved because the offence was completed by delivering such an essentially irregular and illegal offer”,  explains Ćubela.

If Srebrena malina could

When asked who will establish the existence of this criminal offence, the Agency replies that the Competition Council of Bosnia and Herzegovina is responsible for the procedure for the protection of market competition.

However, the BiH Competition Council says that they are not competent to interpret the Law on Public Procurement. However, they recommend that, if we have information about violations of market competition, we can provide them with evidence and relevant information or initiate proceedings.

 

Directors of several hospitals in Bosnia and Herzegovina, refusing to speak publicly about public procurement, appreciate that there is competition in the medical equipment market in Bosnia and Herzegovina. As with anything anyone wants to buy. They warn that it is probably either an agreement between the bidders or a very precisely copied description of the requested goods.

 

“If Srebrena malina could sell respirators – why can’t others”, says one of the interlocutors.

 Messy and imprecise

A cursory look at the data on public procurement on the KCUS website (https://www.kcus.ba/javne-nabavke-svi/) shows that records are kept irregularly and imprecisely. Interview.ba

clinical centar
Podijeli: Facebook Twitter LinkedIn WhatsApp Copy Link Email
Prethodni članakHrana će još poskupljivati
Sljedeći članak Najava događaja za nedjelju, 19. februar 2023. godine

Povezani članci

NOVOSTI 22 minute čitanja

Poslodavci protiv rasta plata i poskupljenja struje

Capital teme 72 minute čitanja

Penzioner na čelu tržišne inspekcije RS

Ostavi komentar Otkaži

NE PROPUSTITE
Capital teme

„Planet Soft“ i „Dwelt“ u trci za izradu softvera ERS

9. Juna 2025. — 14:1802 minute čitanja

Procijenjena vrijednost nabavke je 22,5 miliona KM bez PDV-a,

Novinarka CAPITAL-a nagrađena za izvještavanje o švercu duvana

9. Juna 2025. — 14:06

Radišić ponovo jedini dostavio ponudu za zgradu UIO

9. Juna 2025. — 12:36

EKSKLUZIVNO: Direktor IRB-a podnio ostavku

9. Juna 2025. — 10:39

Portal CAPITAL.ba je punopravni član Savjeta za štampu i online medije u BiH, Journalism Trust Inicijative i Reporters Shields Network.

Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram LinkedIn YouTube Viber
  • Uređivačka politika
  • O nama
  • Impressum
  • Kontakt
  • Marketing
  • Piši za Capital
  • ENERGETIKA RS
  • SLOBODNO
Copyright © 2025 Capital.ba - ISSN 2744-225X. Sva prava rezervisana.
Portal CAPITAL.ba je punopravni član Savjeta za štampu i online medije u BiH.

Unesite iznad pojam sa pretragu i pritisnite Enter za pretragu. Pritisnite Esc ili X da otkažete.

Obavijesti